Deliciously Easy Pumpkin Spice Treats to Savor This Season

Table of Contents

Pumpkin spice always makes me think of chilly nights and sweaters that itch your neck just a little. You know the deal, you wake up and suddenly you’ve got the wild urge to add pumpkin spice to anything you can get your hands on. Lattes, muffins, even oatmeal if you’re wild like me. If you’re staring at store-bought mixes (with their mystery ingredients and truly questionable price tags), I feel you.

Sometimes you just want to know what’s actually going into your food. Plus, homemade is just better, sorry, it just is. If you’ve never tried throwing together your own blend, you’re missing out. It only takes five minutes, tops. And hey, if you’re diving in, you’ll want to see these baked pumpkin spice donuts or maybe give this coffee pumpkin pie delight a look. Both are absolute musts for pumpkin spice fans.

Make Your Own Pumpkin Pie Spice

Honestly, making your own pumpkin pie spice is as easy as falling off a log. And believe me, if I (queen of shortcuts and skipping directions) can do this, literally anyone can. Basically, all you need is a few basics from your spice rack. No secret ingredients. No hard-to-find stuff. I actually started blending my own when I ran out mid-baking and realized shipping would take a week, so I just made do. Turns out my homemade batch tasted way fresher than what I’d been buying. You can adjust the flavors exactly how you like. More cinnamon? Yes, please. Dial up the nutmeg? Toss it in. It’s DIY comfort in a jar.

Let me just say, once you start making your own, you’ll feel sort of like a kitchen wizard. You get a boost of flavor, plus this lovely homemade touch that makes everyone ask, “What’s your secret?” Uh, not telling (unless they promise to do my dishes). You’ll save money too. I mean, do yourself a favor and whip up a small batch. Thank me later, okay?

“Made my own pumpkin pie spice after reading this and I swear, my muffins have never tasted so fresh. My kids even noticed! Game changer.” Jessa from Vermont

Ingredients You Need for Pumpkin Pie Spice

You probably already have everything for pumpkin pie spice hanging out in your cupboard, just collecting dust. Grab these:

• 3 tablespoons ground cinnamon (seriously, don’t skimp)
• 2 teaspoons ground ginger (keep it punchy)
• 2 teaspoons ground nutmeg (freshly grated if you’re fancy)
• 1.5 teaspoons ground allspice
• 1.5 teaspoons ground cloves

No extra shopping required, most likely. If you’re out of one, just mix what you have. Trust me; it’ll still be good. Stir it together in a small airtight jar. That’s it. Sometimes I’ll double up, if I’m feeling ambitious or if the fall baking bug really bites.

How Long Can I Store Pumpkin Pie Spice?

Let’s keep this real. Your pumpkin pie spice is not going to last forever, but it sure hangs in there for a good while. If you store it in a clean, airtight container (old jelly jar, anyone?), you’re easily looking at 6 months, probably longer. I taste mine after a few months just to see if the kick is still there. If it starts to lose that autumn punch, time for a fresh batch. Keep moisture out, so no sprinkling it right over a steamy pot. Cabinets work way better than putting it above the stove (learned that one the hard way). Just label your jar, write the date on it, and you’re golden. Simple, right?

Uses for Your Pumpkin Pie Spice

Once you have this blend on hand, you’ll look for excuses to sprinkle it on anything. I mean, sky’s the limit once you get that first whiff.

• Perfect in pancakes (seriously, check out these fluffy pumpkin pancakes if you want proof)
• Mix into hot coffee or a homemade latte for a DIY coffee shop vibe
• Sprinkle over roasted sweet potatoes for a cozy twist
• Stir some into oatmeal or yogurt and thank me later

Don’t feel boxed in. Half the fun is coming up with quirky new combos. For something different, those pumpkin nutella cookies are a hit with my family (and wow, do they disappear fast).

Ingredient	Quantity	Notes
Ground Cinnamon	3 tablespoons	Core flavor of pumpkin spice
Ground Ginger	2 teaspoons	Adds a warm zest
Ground Nutmeg	2 teaspoons	Best fresh grated for flavor
Ground Allspice	1.5 teaspoons	Gives a unique twist
Ground Cloves	1.5 teaspoons	Strong flavor, use sparingly

My Top Success Tip

Here’s my truth: fresh spices matter more than I ever thought. Don’t be like past-me using those ancient spice bottles from who-knows-when. Your pumpkin pie spice will only be as good as the ingredients you start with. Buy smaller amounts and restock each fall if you use it up. If your cinnamon barely smells like anything, get a new jar. Trust me, it makes a night-and-day difference. Another quick tip? Shake up your jar before each use so nothing settles and you always get a balanced hit of flavor. Let the spice do the talking. Easy win.

Beyond the cozy flavor, pumpkin spice also comes with real health perks. The classic blend cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves packs plenty of antioxidants, may help reduce inflammation, and can even support digestive health. Recent studies show that cinnamon can lower cholesterol, ginger aids joint pain and digestion, while nutmeg provides minerals like magnesium and iron. Discover more about the science-backed benefits of pumpkin spice in this Cleveland Clinic article dedicated to why this fall favorite does more than just taste good.

FAQs

Ready for Pumpkin Spice Perfection?

So there you have it. Making your own pumpkin pie spice is simple, budget-friendly, and packs a punch in every dish. Go nuts (well, maybe not literally) and start experimenting with your own blends. I’ll tell you, recipes like this homemade pumpkin pie spice from Sally’s Baking Addiction are a handy starting point, or check out The Pioneer Woman’s easy pumpkin spice method if you need a second opinion. And for a laugh, did you read about that weird pumpkin spice week on The Atlantic? Anyway, don’t wait until the shelves are empty this season. Go DIY, make it yours, and see what delicious magic you can bring to the table.

Print